I'd say this is the best PotC movie since the first one back in early 2000's.
But seriously, if you despised 'On Stranger Tides', this one you'll probably like. Perhaps this familiarity is what makes critics hate it. There's also a familiar feels to the first movie in this one. The amount of screen time of Orlando Bloom and Keira Knightley probably means that there'll be more of these movies in the future. The actions are more grounded than the previous movies, and they managed to salvage themselves after the less-than-mediocre 'On Stranger Tides'. While continuity errors are somewhat blatant, you can't say this movie is the worst of the 5 PotC movies. While the previous Pirates of the Caribbean (PotC) movie feels more like a spin-off than a direct sequel to the original trilogy, 'Dead Men Tell No Tales/Salazar's Revenge' continues the lore of the first 3 movies. Expectations is everything with these movies.
